In the heart of the Adirondacks, where the pines claw at the sky and the lakes shimmer like liquid obsidian, two fishermen stood on the bank of Blackthorn Lake. Amos Reed and Caleb Holt had been coming here since they were boys, their rods extensions of their arms, their silence a language honed over decades.
The lake was their sanctuary, a place to escape the grind of their lives in the nearby mill town of Harrow’s End. Amos, a widower with a limp from a logging accident, carried the weight of a life unlived.
Caleb, a father of three with a wife who’d grown distant, fished to drown out the noise of his regrets. Bound by routine, the rhythm of casting lines, he hoped for the feel of a tug.
Tonight, under a moonless sky, the air was thick with mist. The lake was unnaturally still, its surface a perfect mirror reflecting the gnarled trees. Amos sipped from a flask, the whiskey burning his throat.
“You ever think about what’s down there?” he asked, his voice low, as if afraid to disturb the water.
Caleb, retying his lure, snorted. “Fish. Mud. Maybe some old boots. What else?”
Amos didn’t answer. He cast his line, the sinker plunking into the depths. The ripples faded quickly–as if the lake swallowed them whole.
They fished in silence, the only sound the creak of their reels and the distant hoot of an owl. Then, Amos’s rod jerked.
“Got one!” he grunted, bracing his boots against the muddy bank.
The line went taut, cutting through the water like a blade. Amos reeled, but the resistance was strange—not the thrashing of a fish, but a steady, deliberate pull.
“Feels like I snagged a damn log.”
Caleb squinted at the water. “Ain’t no log. Look at your line—it’s movin’ sideways.”
Amos’s brow furrowed. The line wasn’t just taut; it vibrated, a low hum rising from the water. His hands tightened on the rod, knuckles white.
“What the hell is this?”
Across the lake—or perhaps not across–but a place that wasn’t quite here—a man named Elias Kane stood on another bank. In his reality, Blackthorn Lake was called Mirror’s End, and the town was a crumbling settlement abandoned after a mine collapse.
Elias was a loner, a man who’d lost his brother to the lake years ago when their boat capsized in a storm. He fished to feel close to Jonah, to chase the ghost of his guilt.
His lake was different—its waters glowed faintly, a sickly green, and the air carried a metallic tang. But tonight, his rod had snagged something.
“Caught somethin’,” Elias muttered, his voice rough from disuse.
He tugged, expecting a sunken branch or a rusted relic from the old mine. But the line pulled back–hard, nearly yanking the rod from his hands.
“What in God’s name…?”
Back on Amos’s bank, the pull grew stronger. His rod bent nearly double, the reel screaming. “This ain’t no fish!”
Caleb stumbled forward but froze. The water where Amos’s line entered was bubbling, not with the frenzy of a hooked bass, but with a slow, deliberate churn, like something was rising. “Amos cut the line. Now.”
“You crazy? I ain’t losin’ my gear!” Amos snapped, sweat beading on his forehead.
But his bravado faltered as the hum from the line grew louder, a sound like a tuning fork struck deep underwater. Then, impossibly, a voice carried through the mist—not from the bank, but from the lake itself.
“Who’s there?” it demanded, sharp and panicked. “Let go of my line!”
Amos froze. Caleb’s jaw dropped.
“You hear that?” Caleb whispered.
“Who’s this?” Amos shouted, his voice cracking. “You messin’ with us?”
On Elias’s bank, he heard the reply, faint–as if spoken through a wall.
“Messin’? You’re the one yankin’ my rod! Cut your line, damn it!”
Elias’s heart pounded. He’d fished these waters for years–always alone and never heard a voice from the lake.
He tugged harder, and the line jerked back, a tug-of-war across an unseen divide.
The glowing water rippled, and for a moment, he swore he saw a shadow beneath the surface—not a fish, but a shape, human-like, distorted.
“Caleb, I’m seein’ things,” Amos said, his voice trembling.
The water before him was no longer still. It shimmered, not with moonlight, but with an unnatural sheen, an oil slick with starlight. The line pulled harder, and the voice came again.
“Stop pullin’! You’re gonna drag me in!” Elias’s voice was desperate now, and Amos could hear the fear in it—a fear that mirrored his own.
“Drag you in?” Amos yelled. “You’re the one haulin’ me! Who are you?”
“Name’s Elias! I’m fishin’ Mirror’s End. Where the hell are you?”
“Blackthorn Lake!” Amos shot back. “Ain’t no Mirror’s End ‘round here!”
Caleb grabbed Amos’s arm.
“This ain’t right. Somethin’s wrong with the lake. Cut the damn line, Amos!”
But Amos couldn’t. The pull was relentless, and now the water was parting, revealing not the muddy bottom but a glimpse of another shore—Elias’s shore, with its glowing water and skeletal trees. And there, standing on that alien bank, was Elias, his rod bent, his face pale with terror.
Elias also saw a window through the water, showing Amos and Caleb on a bank that shouldn’t exist. The air between them crackled, the hum now a deafening drone. Each line intertwined across the rift where the realities collided.
“What’s happenin’?” Elias shouted, his voice distorted–as if underwater.
“What is this place?”
“I don’t know!” Amos roared, his arms burning from the strain. “But I ain’t lettin’ go!”
The water churned violently now, and both men saw it—the shape beneath, no longer a shadow but a presence, vast and formless, its edges flickering like static. It wasn’t a fish or a man; it was something older, a being that had waited in the depths of both lakes or perhaps in the space between them, fishing lines anchored to it.
“Amos, it’s pullin’ us both!” Caleb screamed, grabbing the rod to help.
But the force was too strong. Amos’s boots slid toward the water, the bank crumbling beneath him.
On Elias’s side, the same was happening. His boots sank into the mud, the glowing water lapping at his ankles.
“Jonah?” he whispered, half-believing his brother’s ghost was behind this.
But the thing in the water wasn’t Jonah. It was hungry.
“Cut the line!” Caleb begged again, but Amos’s hands were locked, his eyes fixed on Elias through the rift. Elias, too, couldn’t let go, his guilt and grief binding him to the rod as much as the line itself.
The presence surged, and the rift widened. Amos saw Elias’s world fully now—its decayed trees, its toxic glow—and Elias saw Amos’s, with its dark pines and mist. But both saw the thing rising, its form coalescing into something neither could comprehend, a mass of writhing shadows and eyes that burned like dying stars.
“God help us,” Amos whispered.
“Jonah, I’m sorry,” Elias sobbed.
The lines snapped simultaneously, but it was too late. The rift collapsed, and the thing broke free.
Yanked into Blackthorn Lake, Amos and Caleb’s screams were swallowed by the water. Elias vanished into Mirror’s End, his cry echoing across a reality that wasn’t his.
The coming morning, Blackthorn Lake was still again, its surface unbroken. Two rods lay abandoned on the bank, their lines severed.
In Harrow’s End, folks whispered that Amos and Caleb had drowned, but they found no bodies. In Elias’s world, the settlement stayed empty, his rod gone from the shore.
But those who fish Blackthorn Lake at night, or Mirror’s End in that other place, say the water hums sometimes, a low, mournful sound. And if you cast your line too deep, you might feel a tug—not from a fish, but from something waiting, something that pulls across worlds, hungry for the ones who dare snag it.