The desert landscape near Devil’s Gate had always held a strange allure for those who wandered its expanse as if some hidden purpose whispered from the parched ground and dry, crackling air.
Nicholas Brandt, a historian and archaeologist in his mid-thirties, was drawn to the region for reasons he could hardly articulate. Officially, he was on a mission to document ghost towns and the folklore they left behind, but some unspoken calling tugged him toward Silver City.
Locals mentioned Jubell’s Café as a place he ought to stop. “Best biscuits and gravy in the county,” they’d say, though the compliments came with a strange, thoughtful silence. The café sat alone on a dusty stretch of State Route 341, the building itself worn and unremarkable, save for a garish wooden sign painted with exaggerated letters: Jubell’s Café – Open from Dawn till Dusk.
Inside, Jubell’s Café was small and dim, bathed in a sickly yellow light that pooled from low-hanging bulbs. Nicholas noticed patrons bent over plates of biscuits and gravy, their expressions distant as if each bite pulled them further into some private trance.
Behind the counter, Magnificent Marsh presided over her kitchen like a figure out of some ancient rite, her movements slow but deliberate. She wore a shapeless black dress that seemed to absorb all light around her, and though her face held the softness of age, something was unsettling in how her eyes seemed to pierce through everything.
In Devilskill, the seacoast town she once called home, Magnificent Marsh had been more than just a high priest; she had been a figure of ominous reverence. Aaron Vlek, a young, ambitious reporter, had once devoted months to uncovering the strange temple she presided over—a place of cryptic rituals and whispered worship along the shore, where the salt of the ocean mingled with the smoke of unknown offerings.
Vlek’s articles painted her and her followers in dark, disturbing tones, stirring fear and suspicion within the community. Soon, Magnificent fled, slipping into obscurity as she vanished westward.
She left behind the ocean and its deep secrets, trading its tides for the dry, silent vastness of the desert. The barren expanse around Devil’s Gate offered an unspoken welcome to those who sought solitude—and those who carried secrets.
In the ghostly quiet of Silver City, she opened Jubell’s Café as if intending to hide in plain sight. The locals noticed her strangeness, but the food was good, and no one asked questions.
“Welcome,” she said, her voice a low hum that vibrated through Nicholas’s chest, though she hadn’t raised her eyes from the stove. He sat at the counter, feeling her voice linger long after she’d spoken, like the low rumble of distant thunder.
He ordered the biscuits and gravy. Magnificent nodded, almost mechanically, as if she knew what he’d want long before he spoke. Soon, she served him a plate, its contents steaming. The aroma was strangely intoxicating—rich, earthy, almost alive.
As he lifted his fork, he couldn’t help but glance into the kitchen, barely able to see beyond a narrow pass-through window cut into the wall. At first, he saw only the folds of Magnificent’s black dress moving like drapery around her shadowed form. But something more beckoned him to look deeper. He leaned over his plate, straining to see into the dim recesses of her kitchen.
To his surprise, she caught his gaze. “Curious, aren’t we?” she murmured.
“Just…admiring the kitchen,” he stammered, though he wasn’t sure why he felt compelled to say it.
A faint, almost mocking smile crossed her lips. “It’s just a kitchen, Mr. Brandt.”
For reasons he could not explain–Nicholas felt an almost painful need to see more. Her gaze seemed to fasten him in place as if daring him to come closer. He told himself he was being irrational, that this strange foreboding was just his overactive imagination—but the pull was undeniable.
Days later, he returned just before closing, as dusk bled into the night and shadows pooled around Jubell’s Café. This time, the café was empty. Nicholas slipped in quietly, taking a seat that gave him an unobstructed view into the kitchen. Magnificent, busy at the stove, didn’t seem to notice him—or, more disturbingly, seemed completely unconcerned by his presence.
He watched as she stirred the thick, white gravy, each movement measured, almost hypnotic. And then, her arm lifted, and Nicholas froze. The skin around her fingers seemed to loosen, sagging like the flesh beneath it was hollow. Slowly, she brought a hand to her chest, slipping it inside the deep collar of her dress.
Nicholas’s heart hammered in his chest as he realized what she was doing.
With a faint groan, she exposed one breast—wrinkled, pale, and glistening with an unnatural sheen. She squeezed it, and a thick cream dripped into the bubbling pot. The substance was not milk but something sickly translucent, a spectral luminescence that made Nicholas’s skin crawl.
In horror, Nicholas watched as she picked up a knife, dull and rusted, and dragged it along her sagging flesh, peeling thin strips of skin that she dropped into the pot. The flesh sizzled as it hit the gravy, emitting a smell he could never have described, both foul and strangely enticing, like charred seaweed on a coastal wind.
The revelation struck him like a blow: this was the “meat” everyone raved about, the secret behind her famous gravy. The horror was too much to bear, and a scream tore itself from his throat before he even knew he’d uttered it.
Magnificent Marsh looked up, her eyes now an unnatural, milky white as if the last trace of life had drained them. She smiled, a slow, chilling smile that spread across her face like a shadow. “I see you’ve taken quite an interest in my recipe, Mr. Brandt,” she whispered, her voice so low it seemed to resonate within his bones.
Nicholas stumbled backward, his legs nearly collapsing beneath him. He turned and bolted for the door, his footsteps loud in the oppressive silence of the empty café.
He didn’t stop running until he reached his truck, throwing himself into the driver’s seat and gunning the engine. As he sped down the road, his mind whirled, his pulse hammering as if to propel him away from the nightmare.
The following morning, his truck, abandoned in the shadow of Kate Peak near the Buckeye Mine, was found, doors open, engine still running, but without any sign of Nicholas Brant.
Back at Jubell’s Café, the locals continued to eat their biscuits and gravy, their faces vacant, eyes glazed, lost in some quiet, dreadful peace. And now and then, from behind the counter, Magnificent Marsh would cast a knowing glance out the window, a secret smile playing on her lips as she stirred the thick, pale gravy that bubbled quietly in her pot.