The Nevada Commission on Ethics split a vote of 2-2, letting Reno Mayor Hillary Schieve off the hook after the third-term politician allegedly violated state ethics laws.
The vote came after an ethics complaint was filed against Schieve in April 2023, alleging she failed to disclose a professional relationship with McDonald Carano, a law firm representing her, and that was involved in a home development project before the city council. The case revolved around Schieve’s hiring the firm to sue a private investigator she accused of electronically stalking her.
The resulting tied vote came because of a vacant seat left by former Commissioner Barbara Gruenewald, creating an even number of voting members. According to Commission on Ethics Chair Kim Wallin, the Legislative Commission, responsible for filling the vacant seat, has yet to take action.
Executive Director Ross Armstrong clarified that a majority was needed to find a violation. The absence of a majority vote means the commissioners had to agree on a final opinion, which will be up for approval in March.
During the meeting, Ethics Commissioner Amanda Yen abstained due to her association with McDonald Carano, and three other commissioners could not vote as they were part of the panel that conducted a preliminary review in November.
City of Reno attorney Jonathan Shipman argued that requiring disclosure of law firm relationships could set a precedent for public officials having to disclose various services they employ. However, Commission on Ethics attorney Elizabeth Bassett countered that attorney-client relationships hold a unique place in public office matters.
With no violation found, Schieve is not obligated to attend ethics training or pay fines.
The Old Blog in the Desert 